‘A culture of availability’: Can litigators ever truly unplug?

Litigation Daily

In August, I did something I’d never done before in my career as a journalist: I went completely off the grid.

For five days, while I backpacked through the Tetons, I was completely unreachable. With zero bars on my phone, I couldn’t have stayed plugged in to the news cycle if I wanted to. During that time, as far as I was concerned, Luigi Mangione was still planning to go to trial in federal court, and Hayden Panettiere was alive and well. If every courthouse in Delaware simultaneously burned to the ground, I’d have had no way of knowing.

It made me wonder how many litigators have ever gotten to go offline like that. It turns out, if you ask litigators if they ever get the chance to unplug, most will say they do. But their version of unplugging often seems to come with the caveat that they must be on call to plug back in as soon as they’re needed. And if they’re preparing for or actively in trial? No way.

Continue reading here.

Delaware’s bench has more women. The Chancery bar is still catching up.

Litigation Daily

In the past decade, Delaware has gradually filled vacancies on its courts with more women than ever before. The Court of Chancery is currently led by its first-ever female chancellor, and two of the five sitting vice chancellors are women. (With former Vice Chancellor Morgan Zurn recently confirmed to the state’s Supreme Court, there’s one open seat.)

But female litigators appearing before those judges say the number of women leading and arguing cases in the Court of Chancery, while improving, is lagging in proportion to the bench.

Continue reading here.

It’s the Delaware Way or the highway: A primer on why Delaware’s corporate bar is so into civility

Litigation Daily

Irascible tort lawyer Joe Jamail once said, “I’d rather have a nose on my ass than go to Delaware for any reason.”

That was in response to the Delaware Supreme Court formally reprimanding Jamail for his conduct during a deposition. More than 30 years later, the Delaware bar still has a culture of being significantly more civil and friendly than other jurisdictions’ norms, a set of standards for legal practice often referred to as “the Delaware Way.”

Continue reading here.

Corporate attorneys know their clients shouldn’t be asking chatbots legal questions. Do the clients?

Litigation Daily

In mid-March, the Delaware Court of Chancery issued a decision concluding South Korean gaming company Krafton Inc. breached its agreement to purchase Unknown Worlds Entertainment, creator of the video game Subnautica, in an effort to evade a $250 million earnout agreement.

There were several attention-grabbing elements to the case, but what litigators immediately zeroed in on was how the court cited Krafton’s CEO’s ChatGPT conversations as evidence.

Continue reading here.

Here’s how noncompetes are being interpreted in contractarian Delaware

Law.com, Litigation Daily

It’s every lawyer’s go-to answer for pretty much every yes or no question: “It depends.”

“It depends” is also the most concise way to describe Delaware’s evolving stance on the enforceability of noncompetes at a time when the topic is getting a lot of attention nationally and some states are passing legislation to mark themselves as categorically for or against trade restrictions in employment contracts.

Delaware courts don’t rubber-stamp noncompetes, but they also don’t have a ban on them like the ones that a handful of other states have enacted through legislation and that the FTC floated before abandoning the effort last year.

Continue reading here.

Head to toe advocacy: How clothes fit into a litigation strategy

Litigation Daily

I’ve watched a lot of arguments in my time covering litigation, which means I’ve seen a lot of lawyers wearing essentially the same thing in the courtroom.

The overwhelming majority of the time, those outfits include a white shirt and a black, navy or charcoal suit. I’ve always wondered about what’s behind that near-uniform. Is it one of those things attorneys just do because that’s what their mentors did? Is it to keep one element simple during an otherwise complex event? And are litigators who deviate from that formula doing so to make a statement?

I asked litigators what they consider when getting dressed for court. More than anything else, those who do go for the white shirt and dark suit said they do so because they want to avoid anything that might distract from what they’re saying.

Continue reading here.

Here’s what corporate governance lawyers want from a decision on Elon Musk’s Tesla compensation appeal

Litigation Daily

It’s finally happening: the big one.

That’s what I’ve had countless litigators and transactional lawyers alike call the appeal of Elon Musk’s compensation case in Delaware when I ask them what cases they’re watching closely. As in, “Well, of course, the big one is Tornetta v. Musk.”

The Delaware Supreme Court will hear argument on the big one today, and after more than six years, all that’s left is for the court to write what’s likely to be one big opinion.

Continue reading here.

To litigate or legislate? The Texas approach to building corporate law

Litigation Daily

When I started thinking about what to write about the one-year anniversary of Texas launching its business courts, two things struck me.

One, despite knowing what’s going on in Texas now being a sizable chunk of my job, I’ve never actually been there (unless you count the time American Airlines changed my flight schedule to include a some-expenses-paid overnight layover in a hotel just outside DFW).

Two, I can’t help but compare the conversation about how Texas’ legislature interacts with its business courts to what we’ve seen and heard this year out of Delaware. The central question in both venues is how much say legislators should have in shaping business law, and how much should be left to the courts.

Continue reading here.

Foot fault? Del. courts weigh when harm from corporate bylaws is beyond theoretical

Litigation Daily

Imagine you’re playing tennis. You’re about to serve, but the line judge stops you. You stepped over the baseline before you hit the ball. There’s a small but persistent group of people who travel from one tennis match to another, focused solely on trying to catch people making that same misstep and getting officials to make a call penalizing them for it.

Maybe you and some others are critical of that small group and believe they’re making a big deal out of a harmless error. But it could be argued that a harmless error still breaks the rules, and maybe that small group is doing something good by trying to catch them.

Continue reading here.

A brief history behind DExit and the biggest beef in Del. corporate law

Litigation Daily

When I’m not covering corporate litigation, one of my guilty pleasures is watching reality television shows on Bravo.

Now that Tom Girardi is done with both, corporate litigation and Bravo don’t typically have much overlap. But in the past two months, the public feuding I’ve seen both during legislative hearings and online has been more dramatic than anything I’m expecting from the “Vanderpump Rules” recasting.

Continue reading here.